Friday, Oct 23, 2026

How to Make the Best Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Getting the perfect grilled cheese sandwich can be hard, but with a few simple steps, you can make it taste great! Here are some tips: Pick a crusty loaf of bread, spread mayonnaise on the outside, and add plenty of cheese! This sandwich is a staple on any summer grilling list! If you're not a fan of the traditional version, try these simple ways to improve your grilled cheese.

Choosing the best cheese for a grilled cheese sandwich

There are many types of cheese available. Some are better than others depending on your personal tastes. For a milder grilled cheese, try mozzarella, which pairs well with a variety of toppings. For a more pungent taste, try ricotta, which melts easily and has a stronger flavor than mozzarella. While all cheeses have their own benefits, you should always choose the kind that suits the sandwich best.

Hard cheeses tend not to melt well, so try to choose a soft type of cheese. You can also add some dried figs or peaches. To create an even creamier grilled cheese sandwich, consider blending several types of cheese. If you are adding more than one type of cheese, be sure to pat it dry first. This will prevent moisture from oozing out during toasting.

Choosing a crusty bread

Choosing a crusty bread for grilled cheese sandwiches is as important as choosing the fillings. A grilled cheese sandwich with a crusty, buttery bread and your favorite cheddar has the perfect combination of melted cheese and a crisp, grilled outside. The right crust also means that the cheese pull is impressive. A day old, stale bread will not work well as a grilled cheese.

A grilled cheese sandwich can be made using a variety of bread types, including white sliced bread. This bread is best for making a classic grilled cheese, but if you want something a little fancier, try a loaf with big holes, like an Italian loaf or round French loaf. If you aren't sure what kind of bread to buy, you can also opt for softer breads such as challah or brioche.

Adding mayonnaise to the outside

Adding mayonnaise to the outside of your grilled cheese sandwich will give it a perfectly golden exterior. This trick works for all types of grilled cheese sandwiches, no matter the filling. Butter is also great inside a grilled cheese sandwich. To give your sandwich the best of both worlds, use both. Then, watch the sandwich carefully. Add more mayo if you like.

Another advantage of mayo over butter is the easier spreadability. A traditional grilled cheese is a well-browned, crisp exterior. Butter is the traditional method of spreading butter on bread, but you can use mayo if you'd prefer a lighter, healthier version. It's a much more convenient option than waiting for the butter to soften and zap in the microwave.

Using a non-melter cheese

Whether you're making grilled cheese sandwiches for yourself or for a crowd, you should make sure that you use a good quality melted, non-melter cheddar or mozzarella cheese. Both varieties are excellent choices. When using non-melter cheese, you'll need to use less than half the recommended amount. You should also avoid packaged shredded cheese, as it may contain fillers or anti-caking ingredients. To create the perfect grilled cheese sandwich, use a box grater or food processor shredding disk. If you're using a soft cheese, you can shred it yourself, but remember not to use the microwave as it will soften the bread.

A sandwich is not complete without the cheese. A good cheese will make your sandwich extra cheesy, but it shouldn't cause the bread to fall apart. The proper amount will depend on the size of the bread, but a general rule is that you should use about one-third of a cup of cheese. To avoid a messy sandwich, use thin slices. You can also use grated cheese, as it melts more easily than regular slices.